Nicole and Stephanie bring on Sheryl McCullum to revisit the missing case of Keeslyn Roberts. Four years later we discuss so many unanswered questions, what seems like a lack in Law Enforcement interest, and what things can be done now in the investigation to shine a light on some truth.

"Anytime you have a remote location, that's open 24-hours a day, that's in a small, know-nothin' town and you've got more than one major incident that occurs there, ain't no way I wouldn't put the spot light right on it." - Sheryl McCullum on this illuminating episode, Missing: Keeslyn Roberts Revisited.

Sheryl “Mac” McCollum is an Emmy Award winning CSI from CBS46’s CSI Atlanta, Director of the Cold Case Investigative Research Institute (CCIRI), a writer for CrimeOnLine, Forensic and Crime Scene Expert for Crime Stories with Nancy Grace, and a CSI for a metro Atlanta Police Department. Sheryl holds a master’s degree in Criminal Justice with an emphasis on Policing. She is the co-author of the textbook., Cold Case: Pathways to Justice.

Sheryl the founder and director of the Cold Case Investigative Research Institute, a 501 c 3, a collaboration between universities and colleges that brings researchers, practitioners, students and the criminal justice community together to advance techniques in solving cold cases and assist families and law enforcement with solvability factors for unsolved homicides, missing persons, and kidnapping cases.

DENNIS ALLEN GAAL

Disturbing! Shocking! A Mississippi man plans a birthday trip to Chattanooga, Tennessee. An online search helps him find the gift he’s been looking for. The gift? A baby boy he plans to sexually abuse. Join Nicole and Stephanie as they shed light on the darkest story yet, the pedophile. Joining them is special guest, renowned psychologist Caryn Stark at carynstark.com.

Resources for today’s pod are WCTV Chattanooga, RAINN.org, The Rape, Abuse, Incest National Network - the nation's largest anti-sexual violence organization, and helpingsurvivors.org an organization on a mission to help heal, educate, and empower people who have been impacted by sexual assault and abuse.

CALEB SMITH

On the four year anniversary of his disappearance, the mother of Caleb Smith has more questions than answers. From missing person up to the mystery surrounding his death, listen as Nicole and Stephanie break down the details and unanswered questions in this closed case.

Share what you know here and contact April Arrington through DM on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/aprilarrington

Sign the petition, urging to have Caleb Smith's case re-opened for investigation, here: https://chng.it/pp2PD7YmkM

Georga Bureau of Investigation here: 1-800-597-TIPS

BETHANY MARKOWSKI

It was a cold and windy Sunday afternoon when Bethany Markowski, just eleven years old, heads into the Old Hickory Mall in Jackson, Tennessee. No one has heard from her or seen her since. It seems she just vanished, or did she? Why was her father asleep in the van while she went in alone? Did she even make it into the mall? Join us as we break down this cold case out of our home state.

If you have any informatin or are submitting a tip, please provide as much information as possible to 1-800-TBI-FIND.

KEESLYN ROBERTS

A 20 year old woman walks into the Flying J and enters an employee only area. When confronted, she drops her bag and heads out the door. Then, she vanishes. Listen as we uncover the details in the disappearance of Keeslyn Roberts.

TIFFANY DIANE HOLBERT

Dedicated mother and grandmother takes her nightly walk and disappears. Where is Tiffany?

WESLEY RIDGE

Beloved hometown son and father vanishes. Now a suspect is arrested for murder but where is Wesley Ridge? Join Nicole and Stephanie as they try to unravel this missing and murdered case out of the Sequatchie Valley.

MATTHEW HENRY

A man goes missing from a parking lot one April morning in 2018. What has been a missing case for 6 years is quickly becoming so cold that a new task force is looking at it as a homecide. Take a listen as Nicole and Stephanie sort out the missing case of Matthew Tyler Henry.

STACY CRAWFORD

How does a mother seemingly vanish into thin air? Who was the last to see her? How is her truck found without her or her belongings? Why is the local police keeping quiet? Join Nicole and Stephanie as they cover the missing case of Stacy Crawford from their own stomping ground in the beautiful Sequatchie Valley.

LAYLA SANTANELLO

Midday in the month of June, this year, twenty-year-old Layla Santanello walks into Marble Slab Creamery. She has a conversation with one of the employees, eats some ice cream, heads out the door and vanishes without leaving a trace. Join us as we break down this ongoing investigation out of our home state, Tennessee.

VICTOR “J.R.” SHOEMAKER, JR

Three boys go out to play on Short Mountain, WV but only two boys return. Who’s the scary man in the woods? What does the psychic claim to know? Is this part of a local satanic cult? What happened to five year old J.R.? Take a listen.

NAHOMI HERNANDEZ

A 14 year old girl shot dead is found in a parking lot on Monteagle Mountain on Sunday, October 8 and has received little to no media coverage. Police haven't reported anything until 2 days ago, releasing a statement with very little progress made. Is this a case of white woman syndrome? Listen as Nicole and Stephanie break down what we know about this case so far and join us in raising some H-E-double-hockey-sticks for answers about what happened to Nahomi Hernandez.

UNKNOWN

A young toddler is found dead on the side of the road in Virginia. How does the “sack of death”, a button, and JC Penny play a role in his mysterious case? Take a listen as Nicole and Stephanie break it down.

JASMINE SINGLETARY, AMIR COSBY, & OAKLEY CARLSON

This week, Nicole and Stephanie go beyond the South to bring you stories of children from Florida, Texas and Washington State. That's right! We are headed westward to cover the murder of 14yo, differently abled Jasmine Singletary, the murder of 3 month old Amir Cosby, and the missing case of Oakley Carlson who would be 6 years old this year. Join us as we try to make sense of the justice system, the Department of Children and Family and what we can do to make a difference.

MADALINA COJOCARI

On November 21, 2022, 11 year old Madalina Cojocari goes missing and her parents don’t report her missing for three weeks! How does five million dollars, the mountains of NC and passports weave this tangled web of deception? Take a listen!

If you have any information concerning the whereabouts of Madalina Cojocari, please contact the the Cornelius Police Department at (704) 892-7773.

You may also contact your local FBI office, the nearest American Embassy or Consulate, or you can submit a tip online at tips.fbi.gov.

CHLOIE LEVERETT & GAGE DANIEL

Up in smoke? Two young children seemingly disappear in a late night fire at their grandparents farmhouse. What happened to 9 year old Chloie and her 7 year old brother Gage? Did they vanish in the night? Where they abducted? Listen, and help us solve this mysterious cold case!

HUMAN TRAFFICKING

Did you know that every 2 minutes a child is bought or sold into sex slavery? Did you know that people can be coerced into debt bondage? And employers all over the country compel people against their will to provide work or service through the use of force, fraud or coercion? Find out all this and more as Nicole and Stephanie cover the 40% increase in human trafficking in their home state of Tennessee. It'll git yer blood boilin'. Just the right feelin' to urge us all into action.

GRANT SOLOMON

On today's pod, Nicole and Stephanie cover the mystery surrounding an incident that takes the life of Grant Solomon. Witnessed only by his father, Grant runs himself over by his own truck. Or did he? In this tell all episode, we cover domestic abuse, sexual abuse, and what really lead to Grant's untimely death. Join us in the jaw dropping, stomach turning episode and get involved in helping bring justice to Grant.

ASHA JAQUILLA DEGREE

This week Nicole and Stephanie cover the story of Asha Degree, who was 9 years old on February 14, 2000 when she awoke in the night, packed a bag, went outside in a horrible storm, walked south on a major highway and then disappeared into the night. Listen to this mysterious case of Asha and the investigation that is still ongoing 23 years later. Contact Detective Adams at the Cleveland Co. Sherriffs office at 704-484-4822 or contact the FBI at 704-672-6100 or 1-800-FBI-FIND.

SHAWNA BETH GARBER

On Episode 3, Nicole and Stephanie cover one of the latest murders possibly connected to BTK, Dennis Rader who is one of the prime suspects in the death of Shawna Beth Garber. She was finally identified in 2021 after being a Grace Doe since 1990. The Osage Sheriffs Department is in an ongoing investigation to see if Shawna Beth and possibly 4 others were indeed victims of BTK killer Dennis Rader. Join us as we break down the investigation, tell what we know of Shawna Beth's life, and her brutal death. Anyone who has information is encouraged to contact Osage Sheriff’s Department at 918-287-3535.